Published · Last updated
The emotional guidance scale is a list of twenty-two emotional states, from joy at the top to powerlessness at the bottom, that comes from the Abraham-Hicks teachings and has spread far beyond them. People search for it as an emotional scale, an emotional ladder, or the Abraham Hicks emotional guidance scale, and most of what they find either sells it as a law-of-attraction manifesting tool or dismisses it entirely. This post takes a therapist’s view: what the scale actually is, which part of it holds up clinically, which part does not, and the one rule inside it that I use with neurodivergent clients because it works regardless of what you believe about vibration.
I’ll call her Esperanza. She is 54, diagnosed with ADHD at 51, and she arrived with the scale printed out and highlighted. A friend had given it to her, and she had been using it for a year to try to “raise her vibration,” which in practice meant that every time she felt anger or grief she judged herself for being low on the list and tried to leap to appreciation. It was not working, and she had concluded that she was spiritually failing. What she had was a decent tool, a bad instruction manual, and a nervous system that does not move from the bottom of a ladder to the top in one step. Nobody’s does.
In this blog post, I describe what the emotional guidance scale is and where it came from, and separate the two things inside it: a ranked list of emotional states, which is useful, and a theory about vibration and attraction, which is not something I can stand behind as a clinician. Then I give you the formula that makes the useful part work, a single rule that turns a list into a practice, and show how it fits a neurodivergent brain in particular. I close with where the scale fits alongside tools with better evidence behind them, so you can use what helps and leave the rest.
3 Key Takeaways
- The emotional guidance scale is two things stapled together: a useful ranked list of emotional states, and a theory of vibration and manifestation that has no clinical support. You can keep the first and drop the second.
- The rule that makes it work is the one-rung rule: reach for the next-best feeling, never the best one. That rule is consistent with what the research on emotion regulation actually finds.
- For neurodivergent adults, the scale’s value is in naming and ordering states, which is hard for many of us, and its risk is in turning emotion into a moral ranking, which many of us are already prone to.
What the Emotional Guidance Scale Is
The scale was published by Esther and Jerry Hicks as part of the Abraham-Hicks teachings, a body of material that presents itself as channeled and that sits squarely in the law-of-attraction tradition. The list itself runs from joy, appreciation, empowerment, freedom, and love at the top, down through contentment, boredom, pessimism, frustration, overwhelm, disappointment, doubt, worry, blame, discouragement, anger, revenge, hatred, jealousy, insecurity and guilt, and finally fear, grief, depression, despair, and powerlessness at the bottom. The teaching attached to it is that each state has a vibrational frequency, that higher frequencies attract better experiences, and that the work of life is to move up the list.
I want to be plain about which part of that I can work with. The ordered list of emotional states is a reasonable rough map. Most people, asked to rank those feelings from most expansive to most constricted, would produce something similar, and having a shared order lets you say “I’m at about worry” in a way that is useful. The vibration and attraction theory is not something the evidence supports, and I do not teach it. I have had clients harmed by it, not by the list but by the implication that their grief was attracting more grief, and I would rather say that clearly than pretend the two halves are inseparable.
Esperanza had absorbed the second half completely. Every low state was evidence she was doing it wrong. That is what I mean by a decent tool with a bad manual.
What Holds Up: The Order, and the Direction
Strip the theory away and two things in the scale survive contact with clinical experience.
The first is that emotional states can be ordered by how much room they leave you. Joy and appreciation are expansive; you can think, plan, connect. Fear, despair, and powerlessness are constricting; the world narrows to the threat. In between sits a long middle where most of life happens. Having words for the middle matters. The research on emotion differentiation finds that people who can distinguish their negative states finely, telling disappointment from discouragement from doubt, cope with distress better than those who lump everything together as “bad” (Kashdan, Barrett, & McKnight, 2015). The scale, whatever its origins, is a list of finely differentiated negative states, and that is its real gift.
The second is the direction of travel. The scale’s own instruction, buried under the manifesting language, is that you move up it one step at a time by reaching for a thought that feels slightly better, not for the best thought you can imagine. From powerlessness, anger is an improvement. From anger, frustration is an improvement. That is clinically sound, and it is the part Esperanza had skipped. She was trying to go from grief to appreciation, which is a leap no nervous system makes, and reading her failure to make it as a failure of character.
The Formula: The One-Rung Rule
Here is the whole practice, as I teach it, in one line: find where you are, then reach for the next rung, never the top.
Find where you are means naming the state as precisely as the list allows. Not “bad.” Discouraged. Not “upset.” Somewhere between worry and blame. This is the differentiation step, and for many neurodivergent adults it is the hardest part, which I come back to below.
Reach for the next rung means asking what thought, action, or shift would move you one place up the list, and only one. From despair, the next rung is grief, which means letting yourself feel the loss rather than the hopelessness. From grief, the next rung is fear or insecurity, which is where you start to want something again. From anger, the next rung is frustration, which is anger that has found something to do. The point is not that these are pleasant. The point is that each one has more room in it than the one below, and that a nervous system can make a one-rung move when it cannot make a ten-rung one.
Never the top means exactly that. The emotional-regulation research draws a clear line between reappraisal, which is changing how you see a situation, and suppression, which is hiding how you feel about it, and finds that reappraisal helps while suppression costs (Gross & John, 2003). Leaping from grief to gratitude is suppression wearing reappraisal’s clothes. It does not change the grief; it buries it under a performance of a feeling you do not have, and the grief waits.
When Esperanza stopped reaching for appreciation and started reaching for one rung, something shifted within a few weeks. From the despair she felt about a strained relationship with her adult son, the next rung was grief, and grief she could actually feel. From grief, the next was fear that she had lost him, and fear she could do something about: she wrote to him. The scale had not changed. The instruction had.
Using It as a Neurodivergent Adult
The scale fits a neurodivergent brain in one way and fights it in another, and both are worth knowing.
It fits because it is a list. For autistic and ADHD adults who find emotions hard to locate, a finite, ordered set of twenty-two words is more usable than “notice what you feel.” A meta-analysis found that roughly half of autistic participants scored above the threshold for alexithymia, difficulty identifying and describing emotions, compared with about one in twenty of the neurotypical comparison participants (Kinnaird, Stewart, & Tchanturia, 2019). For that half, a list to point at is a real accommodation. Some of my clients keep the scale next to the feelings wheel, using the wheel to find the word and the scale to find the direction.
It fights because it is a ranking. Many neurodivergent adults have spent a lifetime being told their reactions were wrong, too much, or in the wrong order, and a scale that puts anger below boredom can read as one more verdict. If you notice yourself using the list to grade your emotions rather than to locate them, that is the manual talking, not the tool. The feelings at the bottom are not failures. They are the states with the least room, and the only job is to find a little more.
There is also a limit the scale does not acknowledge. Some low states are not emotional positions at all. Shutdown, sensory overload, and autistic burnout look like despair on the list and are physiological, not attitudinal, and no better-feeling thought moves them. For those, the better map is one built on the nervous system rather than on mood, and I have written about it as the sensory ladder. Knowing which ladder you are on is most of the skill.
Where It Fits Among Better Tools
I use the scale the way I would use any client’s own map: with respect for what it does and no obligation to its theory. It sits, in my practice, alongside three things with stronger evidence. The feelings wheel, for finding the word. The sensory ladder, for telling emotional states from nervous-system states. And a daily written check-in, which for many neurodivergent adults is the place the one-rung rule actually gets practiced, and which I have written about under neurodivergent journaling.
What I would not do is replace treatment with it. A person at the bottom of the scale for weeks is describing something that may need a professional, and the scale’s own framing, that despair is a low vibration to be climbed out of, can keep people from asking for help they need. If that is where you are, the next rung is a conversation with someone, not a better-feeling thought.
Where This Leaves You
Esperanza still has the printout. The highlighting is different now: the one-rung rule is underlined twice, and the paragraphs about vibration have a pencil line through them, which she drew herself. She uses the list to find where she is, most mornings, and to pick the next step, and she has stopped grading herself for being on it at all.
If you have been using an emotional scale and feeling worse for it, the problem is almost certainly the manual rather than you. And if you cannot find where you are on any list, which is common and not a failing, that is work I do with clients every week. You are welcome to Book a FREE 20-minute “Clarity & Connection” Zoom session. Therapy for neurodivergent adults at Love on the Autism Spectrum is built around exactly this kind of practical, one-rung work.
I’m Barbara (Blaze) Lazarony, MA, LMFT #151788. I work with neurodiverse couples and neurodivergent adults, including people who have been handed a tool with the wrong instructions and concluded that they were the problem.
Client stories referenced in this post are composites, with identifying details changed to protect privacy.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the emotional guidance scale?
It is a ranked list of twenty-two emotional states, from joy at the top to powerlessness at the bottom, published by Esther and Jerry Hicks as part of the Abraham-Hicks teachings. The list is attached to a theory that each state has a vibrational frequency that attracts experiences. The ordered list is a usable map of emotional states; the vibration theory is not supported by evidence, and the two can be separated.
How do you move up the emotional guidance scale?
One rung at a time. Name where you are as precisely as the list allows, then reach for the thought or action that moves you one place up, never the top. From despair the next rung is grief; from anger it is frustration. This matches what emotion-regulation research finds: changing how you see a situation helps, while leaping to a feeling you do not have is suppression, and it costs you.
Is the emotional guidance scale scientific?
The vibration and manifestation theory is not. The idea that emotional states can be ordered by how much room they leave you, and that distinguishing them finely helps you cope, is consistent with research on emotion differentiation. In my practice I use the list and leave the theory, and I say so to clients, because the theory has a way of turning grief into a personal failure.
Does the emotional guidance scale work for autistic or ADHD adults?
The list often helps, because a finite set of ordered words is easier to use than “notice what you feel” for people who find emotions hard to locate. The ranking can hurt, because many neurodivergent adults already grade their own reactions harshly. And some low states, shutdown, sensory overload, and burnout, are physiological rather than emotional and need a nervous-system map rather than a better-feeling thought.
References
Gross, J. J., & John, O. P. (2003). Individual differences in two emotion regulation processes: Implications for affect, relationships, and well-being. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 85(2), 348–362. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.85.2.348
Kashdan, T. B., Barrett, L. F., & McKnight, P. E. (2015). Unpacking emotion differentiation: Transforming unpleasant experience by perceiving distinctions in negativity. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 24(1), 10–16. https://doi.org/10.1177/0963721414550708
Kinnaird, E., Stewart, C., & Tchanturia, K. (2019). Investigating alexithymia in autism: A systematic review and meta-analysis. European Psychiatry, 55, 80–89. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eurpsy.2018.09.004




